Republicans Say They're Cool With Trump Deploying Troops Against Protesters
GOP House Speaker Mike Johnson and Republican Sens. Markwayne Mullin and James Lankford support Donald Trump deploying the National Guard to L.A.
The U.S. secretary of defense has threatened to send active-duty Marines into the streets of Los Angeles to confront protesters opposing the administrationâs detention and deportation of immigrants. At least three prominent Republicans donât seem concerned about potential overreach.
âThe [Department of Defense] is mobilizing the National Guard IMMEDIATELY to support federal law enforcement in Los Angeles. And, if violence continues, active duty Marines at Camp Pendleton will also be mobilized â they are on high alert,â Hegseth wrote late Saturday on X, formerly Twitter, on his personal account.
This prompted ABCâs Jonathan Karl to ask House Speaker Mike Johnson: âCould we really see active duty Marines on the streets of Los Angeles?â
âOne of our core principles is maintaining peace through strength,â Johnson said during an interview on Sundayâs episode of This Week. âWe do that on foreign affairs and domestic affairs as well. I donât think thatâs heavy handed. I think thatâs an important signal.â
âYou donât think sending Marines into the streets of an American city is heavy-handed?â Karl asked.
âWe have to be prepared to do what is necessary, and I think the notice that that might happen might have the deterring effect,â Johnson said.
Active-duty military troops have not been sent in to suppress unrest since the 1992 Los Angeles protests after a jury acquitted four white police officers in the beating of Rodney King, a Black man who was pulled over for a traffic violation. The Posse Comitatus Act prohibits federal troops from engaging in civilian law enforcement unless there is a clear legal or constitutional basis for doing so. It was created to restrict the presidentâs ability to use the military against civilians. The exception to Posse Comitatus is the Insurrection Act, which Trump has not invoked.
Instead, Trump invoked Title 10 of the U.S. Code on Armed Services, which limits the troopsâ actions to protecting federal officials rather than enforcing laws. Title 10 gives Trump authority to deploy the National Guard during âa rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United Statesâ and two other specific circumstances. Chris Mirasola of Lawfare wrote that Trumpâs justification for using this authority is âfactually contestable and, even on the face of the memorandum, unusually weak.â
Republican Sen. James Lankford on NBCâs Meet the Press argued that by deploying the National Guard, Trump is âtrying to deescalate all the tensions that are there.â Newsom has said that Trump activating National Guard troops is âpurposefully inflammatory and will only escalate tensionsâ
âThis is an American city, and to be able to have an American city where we have people literally flying Mexican flags and saying, âYou cannot arrest us,â cannot be allowed,â Lankford said on Sunday. âIf someone violates the law, no matter what state that theyâre in, theyâre in violation of a federal law. They should face consequences for that.â
Republican Sen. Markwayne Mullin also criticized protesters for carrying Mexican flags. âThey were literally out there protesting, carrying a foreign flag. That is absolutely insane. They are not just peaceful protesters. These are illegals,â he said Sunday on State of the Union.
âCarrying a flag is not illegal, as you know,â CNNâs Dana Bash responded.
âForeign flag while youâre attacking law enforcement, itâs pretty bad,â Mullin said.
Carrying a Mexican flag and saying âYou cannot arrest usâ is not a prosecutable offense. It is free speech protected by the First Amendment. And the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) has been clear that anyone found destructing property will be arrested.
âEveryone has the right to peacefully assemble and voice their opinions,â LAPD posted on X. âHowever, vandalizing property and attempting to seriously injure officers, whether Federal or LAPD, is not peaceful.â
When Meet the Press host Kristen Welker pointed out to Lankford that âGovernor Newsom says there is no unmet law enforcement need. The LAPD says the protests were peaceful,â the senator claimed that it is âclearâ that the LAPD is âbeing overwhelmed.â (LAPD has not said they are overwhelmed.)
âThis wouldnât be an issue if California didnât promote sanctuary city policies to be able to tell people literally, âYou can violate federal law and live in our state, and no one will arrest you for this,'â Lankford said. âNow suddenly when they are arrested for federal crimes then suddenly they go into this kind of protest saying, âNo, you canât arrest us here. Weâre immune from federal law.â Thatâs not true.â
Here, Lankford is being misleading. Sanctuary city policies do not grant anyone immunity, they only limit how state and local resources are allocated to aid federal immigration enforcement. Under the Tenth Amendment, states have the right to allocate resources as they see fit, and states have used that amendment in court to justify not assisting with federal immigration raids.
Itâs disturbing that prominent GOP lawmakers are signing on to the presidentâs use of authority to activate the National Guard â against a governorâs wishes â and signaling their agreement that deploying active duty Marines against civilians would be fine with them should Trump choose to do so.
âDonât kid yourself they know they are absolutely getting cooked politically [with] their terrible bill and rising prices, and they want to create a violent spectacle to feed their content machine,â Democratic Sen. Brian Schatz posted on X late Saturday. âItâs time for the mainstream media to describe this authoritarian madness accurately.â